Your search results

Smith Tower: How to Lose Money

Posted by Johnine Larsen on October 25, 2018
| 0

smith-tower-1620954_640

The Smith Tower is being sold AGAIN. After a fresh round of 2015 renovations to the observation deck (complete with a brand-new speakeasy), Unico Properties is selling. Three years was long enough, evidently. The new owner: Goldman Sachs.

Based on precedent, Goldman Sachs is likely to lose money on Seattle’s first skyscraper. Smith Tower has a long history of inflicting financial trouble on ambitious real estate investors. Here’s its story:

 

Seattle_-_Smith_Tower_under_construction_-_1913

1914–1924: The 1900s’ Donald Trump

Lyman Conelius Smith, made rich by guns and typewriters, built the Smith Tower to impress. At the time, Seattle was the “fastest growing city in America,” and Smith wanted to make his mark there. He built the tallest tower west of the Mississippi, and he spared no expense in gaudiness.

Onyx covered the lobby, and the gold doors were engraved with LCSmith. The most ostentatious and popular styles of the time appeared throughout the building, and the elevators used state-of-the-art technology (those original elevators are still in use today—manually operated, maintained by Otis, and designated as a historic landmark). The lavishness certainly impressed Seattle: on opening day, July 4, 1904, 4,400 visitors rode the elevators to the 35th-floor observation area (25 cents apiece) to admire never-before-seen views of Seattle, the Puget Sound, and the Cascade Mountains.

Lyman Cornelius Smith wanted a legacy, and his tower made one. He was also rich enough not to care the exorbitant cost of building it. The Smith family was unable to turn a profit on the building.

 

1924–1976: Many owners

Burns Lyman Smith, Cornelius’s son, owned Smith Tower for just ten years. Then a series of owners rotated in and out of possession, none of them making money on the investment.

 

smithflags

1976–1985: Ivar’s Fish and Skyscrapers

Ivar Haglund—our beloved Fish & Chips Ivar—bought the Smith Tower for $1.8 million in 1976. Almost immediately afterward, he took a trip to outfit his new tower, particularly its Chinese Room Observatory, with authentic Asian artifacts. On a less authentic whim, Ivar added a 16-foot-long windsock to the top of Smith Tower, dubbed “The Rainbow Salmon.” Fifty-plus years after its construction, Ivar Haglund was reportedly the first owner to make money on the investment.

 

1985–1996: Dilapidation

Smith Tower remained an icon on the Seattle skyline, but not a profitable one.

 

1996–2006: Renovations

Smith Tower was in rough shape by the time Samis Land Company bought it for a paltry $7.6 million. Ninety-plus years had worn the Seattle icon into a “fixer upper,” which was a plus, not a negative, for Samis Land Co., which at the time was considered “the king of dilapidated downtown buildings.”

Samis Land Co. invested $27 million in fixing up the fixer-upper. Part of the renovations included converting the caretaker’s apartment inside the pyramid cap into a luxurious, two-story penthouse. That penthouse is still occupied today (and looks like THE dream home).

 

smith3

2006–2011: Housing and (unfulfilled) Hopes

Walton Street Capital bought Smith Tower with plans to turn it into housing space. They obtained permission for condominium conversion from office use, but then—recession. Seattle’s housing bubble popped, deafeningly so, and Walton Street Capital’s plans crumbled.

 

2011–2015: A profit!

In 2011, CBRE Group purchased the $42.5 million mortgage in default on the Smith Tower. At that time, the tower sat 70 percent vacant, operating costs outpaced rent income, and a King County assessment valued the property at less than half of its $42.5 million mortgage.

However, as Seattle recovered from the housing bubble and the city attracted more and more newcomers, Smith Tower recovered, too. After just four years, CBRE Group sold the tower for $73.7 million—almost double its original investment. CBRE Group was Smith Tower’s 20th owner.

 

smith-tower-1620954_640

2015–2018: High Hopes

Unico Properties now owns Smith Tower. It has remodeled the public areas, and as of August 25, 2015, the Smith Tower is open for exploration. There’s a new ground-floor market, and visitors can pay $19.14 (a nod to the tower’s origin) for a self-guided tour or $10 for a historic elevator ride to the speakeasy-style bar on the observation deck.

 

2018–Present: Big Money from the Big Apple

Goldman Sachs is buying the Smith Tower in a package deal—sort of a like a silent auction basket, but with skyscrapers. Goldman Sachs will pay Unico Properties $750 million for a “portfolio” of properties in Seattle and Denver. The details aren’t public, but King County assessed the Smith Tower at $113 million. Can big New York money change the trajectory of Smith Tower? Or will Goldman Sachs just be the next temporary owner in the revolving door that is Seattle’s original skyscraper?

 

 

As Smith Tower demonstrates, real estate investment doesn’t always pan out. Ivar and CBRE Group made out on the tower, but no one else turned a profit on the deal.

It’s a tale of caution that applies to smaller real estate investments, too—not just $131 million investments like Smith Tower. Effective real estate investing takes research, wisdom, and most importantly, experience, to navigate real estate investment successfully, and that’s where we come in. We’ll help you make a sound decision, and we’ll help you find a house that will stay in the black. Take a look around our website, hear what our past clients have to say, and give us a call!

  • Brian Heagler
    Brian Heagler
    16:55 02 Jun 19
    I have worked with Johnine and her team for 19 years and have always received personal, knowledgeable and professional service and attention! There is never and pressure and they will guide you away from a property when appropriate, which is always appreciated when a market is hot and the tendency is to move quickly. I trust them and have never been let down!
    Anne Slater
    Anne Slater
    18:03 25 May 19
    Johnine Larsen is fabulous! She listened and came up with ways we could get what we wanted in a house and stay within our limited budget. When we found the house we wanted, she moved super fast to get the house inspected and implemented creative ideas to make our offer appealing. And out of 13 offers, we were selected and got our house. I recommend her to anyone buying a home.
    Amy Burdick
    Amy Burdick
    19:13 24 May 19
    Real Estate Gals made sure we found our perfect house! Then, when we were up against other bidders, Johnine worked tirelessly to ensure we were tops! Her extensive real estate experience combined with exceptional character and integrity provided peace of mind throughout the process. She also made sure we received the right value as a seller and got the transaction done quickly and efficiently. Simply stated: there is nobody better to help you find your dream home.
    Bill Hollman
    Bill Hollman
    22:21 19 May 19
    I'd give Real Estate Gals 6 stars if I could. We have used them multiple times, both in selling and buying homes in Seattle and the surrounding area. I can't say enough about the professionalism, knowledge, and patience they bring to the task of buying a new home, or selling your current residence. And they know the Seattle area so well, they'll offer valuable insights into the pros and cons of any location you may be to considering. Look no further, call Johnine at Real Estate Gals. You will be glad you did!
    Beth Guerra
    Beth Guerra
    01:14 18 May 19
    Johnine was a breath of fresh air in the real estate market. She listened intently to our wishes and goals, and was tireless in her search for our perfect house. She is well versed in both Seattle and the surrounding areas. She made sure all the details were taken care of after the inspection, and made the closing process seamless. She even gifted us with a housewarming present. Nearly 7 years later, we still receive holiday cards and well wishes. I highly recommend Real Estate Gals and will look no further in the future.
    Aidan Key
    Aidan Key
    15:44 17 May 19
    Johnine and the Real Estate Gals brilliantly took us through the home buying process two different times. Their willingness to educate (I was new), hear our home hopes, and support us through the process are a few of the reasons that I highly recommend this team. Speaking of a team, I love their collaborative business model - it meant that we--the home buyers--always had a returned phone call and an ability to look at a house on OUR schedule. Truly felt like they place the customer first!
    See All Reviews